Thanksgiving-Inspired Cocktail Recipes
These are four Thanksgiving cocktails with full measures, not a theory of what belongs next to turkey. I make a cranberry bourbon sour, an apple cider old fashioned, a sage gin sour, and a sherry cobbler-style glass that I label as the lower-alcohol option. They taste of cranberry and maple, concentrated apple, sage, and nutty sherry. If you like one of those flavours in November, pour it. I am not going to claim a better match than your own mouth.
Cranberry bourbon sour
- 60 ml bourbon
- 30 ml cranberry juice
- 20 ml fresh lemon juice
- 15 ml maple syrup
Shake everything hard with ice and strain into a rocks glass over one large cube. The cranberry should be the sharp kind, not a cranberry drink that is mostly sweetened apple. Thirty millilitres is enough colour and acid. Maple at 15 ml rounds the edges without turning the bourbon into breakfast. If your bottle of juice is already very sweet, drop the maple to 10 ml and taste again. It drinks tart, then maple, then bourbon. I like it before a long meal because it is short and cold. That is preference, not a rule about food.
Apple cider old fashioned
- 60 ml rye whiskey
- 15 ml apple cider reduction, or 10 ml cider syrup
- 2 dashes Angostura bitters
To make the reduction, simmer 200 ml of fresh apple cider in a small pan until 50 ml remains. Cool it. Fifteen millilitres goes into the mixing glass, so one batch covers three drinks with a little left over. If you already own a bottled cider syrup, use 10 ml of that instead of the 15 ml reduction. Do not use them both.
Stir the rye, the reduction, and the bitters with ice until cold, then strain over a large cube. Express a piece of orange peel over the top and drop it in only if you want the oil to keep going. It tastes of rye spice, cooked apple, and bitters. It is an old fashioned that has borrowed cider, not a mug of cider with whiskey waved over it. Bourbon will do if rye is not on the shelf, and it will taste rounder and a little softer. I still start with rye.
Sage gin sour
- 50 ml dry gin
- 25 ml fresh lemon juice
- 15 ml 1:1 simple syrup
- 4 sage leaves
Put the sage in the shaker with the lemon and the syrup. Press the leaves once. Add the gin and ice, shake, and double-strain into a coupe. The gin is 50 ml rather than a heavier pour because sage gets loud when the leaves are shredded, and four intact leaves are the dose I trust. One press. If you pound the sage into confetti the drink smells like a roast pan and tastes bitter. It should taste of lemon, a little sugar, juniper, and sage that you can name. Use the grey-green leaves, not the dusty ones, and do not add a fifth for luck.
Sherry cobbler, the lighter glass
This one is clearly the lower-alcohol option. It is a sherry cobbler style serve, not a spirit sour pretending to behave.
- 90 ml amontillado sherry
- 15 ml 1:1 simple syrup
- An orange wheel or a long peel
- Crushed ice
Add the syrup and the orange to a rocks glass, pour the amontillado, fill with crushed ice, and stir until the outside chills. Amontillado is a fortified wine, well below the strength of the bourbon and the rye in the other glasses, and 90 ml of it is a proper glass of sherry rather than a disguised double. It tastes nutty, a little dry, and refreshed by the orange and the melt. I put it on the table for anyone who wants one drink that is not a 60 ml spirit pour. I do not tell them it is the same kind of drink as the old fashioned. It is not.
None of these need a special November blessing. Reduce the cider in the afternoon, juice the lemons, and leave the shaking until someone asks. If you want more quick seasonal builds in the same mood, I keep a separate list of five quick autumn cocktails. This page is the four I actually repeat when the turkey is the main event and the drinks have to be finished before I go back to the oven. One glass at a time. The sherry is the one I am happy to see in a second round, because I have already said it is the lighter pour.
Cream sherry is the wrong bottle for that cobbler. It is heavier and sweeter, and with syrup already in the glass it drinks like pudding. Stay with amontillado. A fino is fine if you want the cobbler even drier, and you keep the 15 ml of syrup so it is not a stern sip with no fruit. Juice the lemons before anyone arrives, and let the cider reduction cool in a jar. Sage and cranberry can wait for the shaker. Both go dull if they sit around already mixed with melting ice. None of this is a pairing manifesto. It is the boring prep that lets you shake a drink in a few minutes and get back to the oven.
These are full-strength serves for adults of legal drinking age. One is a drink, not a starter. If you are driving, pregnant, or on medication, skip the alcohol.
A long bourbon and cider for the middle of the meal
The cider old fashioned on this page is the short drink, rye stirred with a reduction, and it is the one I want before everyone sits down. Once the plates are out, a second rocks glass of whiskey is a lot, and the sherry cobbler is already spoken for as the lighter glass. What I make in the gap is a highball that uses the same reduction so the afternoon’s simmering was not a one-drink project. The bourbon stays at 60 ml. The length comes from soda and ice, not from pretending the whiskey is a teaspoon.
- 60 ml bourbon
- 15 ml apple cider reduction, the same one as the old fashioned: 200 ml cider simmered to 50 ml
- 15 ml fresh lemon juice
- 2 dashes Angostura bitters
- Cold soda water, to top
- A wide strip of orange peel
Build it in a tall glass. Bourbon, reduction, lemon and bitters over ice, soda to just under the rim, then a short stir. Express the orange peel over the top and drop it in. It should taste of bourbon, cooked apple and a clean lemon edge, with the bitters in the background. It should not taste like a pint of cider that met a bottle in passing. If it does, the soda ran too long or the reduction was never reduced. Fifteen millilitres of a proper reduction is concentrated. Fifteen millilitres of ordinary cloudy cider is a drop in a tall glass and will disappear, which is why the simmer is not optional for this spec either.
Use the reduction or a bottled cider syrup, not both. If you are using a bottled cider syrup, drop it to 10 ml, as in the old fashioned, because those syrups are usually sweeter and thicker than a pan reduction you made yourself. Rye can replace the bourbon if you want the spice louder. I use bourbon here because the lemon and the soda already sharpen the drink, and rye on top of that can taste skinny. Do not add maple as well. Maple lives in the cranberry sour at 15 ml. Stacking it into this highball makes a breakfast drink with whiskey in it, and you will be tempted to pour a longer soda to hide the sugar, which only hides the bourbon.
Eight cranberry sours, shaken two at a time
The cranberry bourbon sour is the one people ask to repeat, so the prep is the mix, not a punch bowl. For eight drinks:
- 480 ml bourbon
- 240 ml sharp cranberry juice
- 160 ml fresh lemon juice
- 120 ml maple syrup
That is eight times 60 ml bourbon, 30 ml cranberry, 20 ml lemon and 15 ml maple. Stir the jug and keep it cold. Lemon and juice sink, maple sits around being sweet, and an unstirred jug means the first glass is sharp and the last one is syrup. One drink is 125 ml of the mix. Shake that with ice and strain over a large cube. Two drinks in a big tin is as far as I will go, then I stop and shake again. Eight in one shaker is how you get a warm, foamy mess and a row of glasses diluting while you look for more ice. If the cranberry is the sweetened kind that is mostly apple, do not multiply it by eight. Drop the maple to 10 ml per drink, which is 80 ml in this jug, and taste a single shake before you commit the rest of the bottle.
What goes wrong
The reduction goes wrong when it does not reduce. If you simmer 200 ml of cider for five minutes and call it done, you still have almost a cup of juice, and 15 ml of it will not season 60 ml of rye or bourbon. It needs to cook down to about 50 ml, then cool. Scorching is the other failure. A pan boiled hard until it smells like burnt sugar will make every drink on this page taste bitter, and lemon will not cover that. Lower the heat once it starts to thicken. Sage goes wrong when the four leaves become a crushed handful. One press, then shake, or the sour tastes like a roasting tin. Cream sherry still does not belong in the cobbler. It is too heavy once the syrup is in the glass. Stay with amontillado, or a fino if you want it drier, and keep the 15 ml of simple syrup so the crushed ice has something to melt into besides stern fortified wine.
None of these is a cure for a long lunch, a late night, or the next morning. Alcohol is the reason a hangover happens, not the thing that sorts one out. Juice the lemons, cool the reduction, and shake when someone asks. One glass, then back to the table. The jug is there so the second round is quick, not so one person can treat eight measures as a single serve.
